TensorNodeStart free trial

FEA Tool manual › Chapter 17

Verification

Chapters
  1. 1 Getting started
  2. 2 The interface
  3. 3 Coordinate systems and conventions
  4. 4 Modelling
  5. 5 Materials
  6. 6 Sections
  7. 7 Supports, releases and modifiers
  8. 8 Loads
  9. 9 Load combinations
  10. 10 Meshing
  11. 11 Static analysis
  12. 12 Dynamic and seismic analysis
  13. 13 Results
  14. 14 Design
  15. 15 Scripting and the AI model builder
  16. 16 Import and export
  17. 17 Verification
  18. 18 Scope and limits
  19. 19 Troubleshooting
  20. 20 Glossary and notation
On this page
  1. 17.1 How the reference values are obtained
  2. 17.2 What is covered
  3. 17.3 Sources
  4. 17.4 What verification does and does not show

The analysis engine of the FEA Tool is checked against problems whose answers are known independently of the engine. This chapter describes how the reference values are obtained, which classes of problem are covered, and the published sources used. Summary counts of the verification of TensorNode as a whole are on the Verification page.

17.1 How the reference values are obtained

Every expected value is computed inside the test itself, from one of three kinds of source, and nothing is copied from the engine's own output:

  1. Closed-form solutions and textbook formulas, such as the deflection and fixed-end moments of a beam, the Euler load of a strut, or the natural frequencies of a cantilever.
  2. Independent numerical solutions of the governing equation, written separately from the engine: the characteristic equation of a shear building solved by bisection on det⁡(K−ω2M)\det(\mathbf{K} - \omega^2\mathbf{M}), the sway buckling load of a portal from the stability functions of Livesley and Chandler, the large-deflection elastica by shooting on θ′′=−(P/EI)cos⁡θ\theta'' = -(P/EI)\cos\theta with a fourth-order Runge-Kutta integration, Duhamel's integral of a half-sine pulse in closed form, and the torsion constant of a rectangle from the Saint-Venant series.
  3. Published values of standards and tables: the spectra and lateral force formulas of the seismic codes, the load combination factors, and the section properties of the steel section tables.

Each check states its tolerance. Where a value is exact in theory (equilibrium, a patch test, a statically determinate beam) the tolerance is close to round-off; where the engine approximates by design (a mesh of plate elements, a circle drawn as a polygon) the tolerance reflects the expected discretisation error, and convergence with mesh refinement is checked as well.

The checks run in the browser on the built app, with the section libraries included, and in a separate script environment on the engine files alone.

17.2 What is covered

Table 17.1 Classes of verification problem
AreaProblemsReference
Frame elementsimply supported, fixed and propped beams under uniform, point, partial and trapezoidal loads; cantilevers; shear deformationRoark Table 8.1; Timoshenko beam theory; the station values are compared at the exact peak
Frames and trussescontinuous beams, portal frames, trussesslope-deflection with axially rigid members, the three-moment equation, the method of joints, virtual work
Supports, releases, offsetssprings, releases, rigid end offsets, fully restrained models, temperaturestatics and the closed-form solution of each case
Second ordercantilever beam-column; amplification of a uniformly loaded pinned memberTimoshenko and Gere: δ=HL33EI⋅3(tan⁡u−u)u3\delta = \frac{HL^3}{3EI}\cdot\frac{3(\tan u - u)}{u^3}; 2(sec⁡u−1)/u22(\sec u - 1)/u^2; AISC 360-22 Appendix 8 B1B_1
BucklingEuler struts; sway buckling of portalsEuler; Livesley and Chandler stability functions
Large displacementthe elastica of a cantilevershooting solution, checked against Bisshopp and Drucker and Mattiasson
Modalcantilever frequencies; shear buildings; participation factors and effective massesβL=1.875104\beta L = 1.875104, 4.694091, 7.854757 (Chopra); characteristic equations
Response spectrummodal combination, directional combinationChopra; Der Kiureghian (1981) for CQC; Gupta and US NRC RG 1.92 for GMC
Time historysingle-degree-of-freedom response to a pulse; energy balanceDuhamel's integral; the piecewise-exact recurrence (Chopra 5.2); Hughes for the energy property of average acceleration
Plasticitycollapse of a propped cantilever (6Mp/L6M_p/L); beam, sway and combined mechanisms of portals, with and without gravityNeal; Horne and Morris
Seismic codesspectra, equivalent lateral force, scaling, storey checksAS 1170.4-2007, ASCE/SEI 7-22, EN 1998-1:2004, NBC 2020; pushover target by ASCE 41-17 Eq. 7-28
Combinationsthe generated factors for each codeAS/NZS 1170.0, ASCE/SEI 7-22, NBC 2020, EN 1990 Annex A1
Sectionslibrary properties; parametric and drawn sections; composite, cracked and transformed sections; interaction and moment-curvature pointsAISC Shapes Database, EN 10365, AS section tables; parallel-axis and thin-wall formulas; the Whitney stress block; plastic theory
Shells and platesmembrane and bending patch tests on distorted meshes; cantilever membranes; simply supported square plates; thermal buckling of a restrained plateMacNeal and Harder (1985); Batoz, Bathe and Ho (1980); the Navier series (Timoshenko)
Area loads and meshinguniform, pattern, hydrostatic and projected loads; area springs; frame-edge matching; the automatic meshstatics and the closed-form solution of each case

As an example of the convergence checks, the central deflection of a simply supported square plate under uniform load, meshed with 4, 8 and 16 MITC4 elements a side, is 0.978, 0.996 and 1.001 times the Navier series value. The mesh guidance of Chapter 10 rests on results of this kind.

17.3 Sources

  • Young, Budynas and Sadegh, Roark's Formulas for Stress and Strain, 8th ed.; Gere and Timoshenko, Mechanics of Materials.
  • Hibbeler, Structural Analysis; McGuire, Gallagher and Ziemian, Matrix Structural Analysis, 2nd ed.
  • Timoshenko and Gere, Theory of Elastic Stability, 2nd ed.; Livesley and Chandler, Stability Functions for Structural Frameworks (1956).
  • Timoshenko and Goodier, Theory of Elasticity; Timoshenko and Woinowsky-Krieger, Theory of Plates and Shells.
  • Chopra, Dynamics of Structures, 5th ed.; Der Kiureghian (1981), Earthquake Engineering and Structural Dynamics 9(5); Wilson, Yuan and Dickens (1982); Hilber, Hughes and Taylor (1977); Bathe, Finite Element Procedures (2014); Gupta (1990).
  • Hughes, The Finite Element Method.
  • Neal, The Plastic Methods of Structural Analysis; Horne and Morris, Plastic Design of Low-Rise Frames.
  • Bisshopp and Drucker (1945), Quarterly of Applied Mathematics 3; Mattiasson (1981), International Journal for Numerical Methods in Engineering 17.
  • MacNeal and Harder (1985), Finite Elements in Analysis and Design 1; Batoz, Bathe and Ho (1980), International Journal for Numerical Methods in Engineering 15.
  • AS 1170.4-2007, ASCE/SEI 7-22, EN 1998-1:2004, NBC 2020, ASCE 41-17, AS/NZS 1170.0:2002, EN 1990:2002+A1, AISC 360-22.

17.4 What verification does and does not show

Agreement with these problems shows that the elements, solvers and code formulas are implemented as described in Chapters 10 to 12. It does not show that a particular model represents a particular structure: the idealisation, the supports and connections, the loads and the mesh remain the engineer's responsibility, and a model should be checked against simple hand calculations as described under reading the results with care.