TensorNodeStart free trial

FEA Tool manual › Chapter 9

Load combinations

Chapters
  1. 1 Getting started
  2. 2 The interface
  3. 3 Coordinate systems and conventions
  4. 4 Modelling
  5. 5 Materials
  6. 6 Sections
  7. 7 Supports, releases and modifiers
  8. 8 Loads
  9. 9 Load combinations
  10. 10 Meshing
  11. 11 Static analysis
  12. 12 Dynamic and seismic analysis
  13. 13 Results
  14. 14 Design
  15. 15 Scripting and the AI model builder
  16. 16 Import and export
  17. 17 Verification
  18. 18 Scope and limits
  19. 19 Troubleshooting
  20. 20 Glossary and notation
On this page
  1. 9.1 How combinations are solved
  2. 9.2 Typed combinations
  3. 9.3 Generating combinations by code
  4. 9.4 AS/NZS 1170.0
  5. 9.5 ASCE/SEI 7-22
  6. 9.6 NBC 2020
  7. 9.7 EN 1990
  8. 9.8 Good practice

A load combination is a factored sum of load patterns. The FEA Tool accepts combinations you type, and generates the strength and serviceability combinations of AS/NZS 1170.0, ASCE/SEI 7-22, NBC 2020 and EN 1990 from the types of the load patterns. This chapter explains how combinations are solved, how the generator works, which combinations it writes for each code and what it leaves to you.

9.1 How combinations are solved

In a linear analysis each load pattern is solved once and a combination is the superposition of its patterns:

uc=∑pλc,p up,sc=∑pλc,p sp(9.1)\mathbf{u}_c = \sum_p \lambda_{c,p}\, \mathbf{u}_p, \qquad \mathbf{s}_c = \sum_p \lambda_{c,p}\, \mathbf{s}_p \tag{9.1}

where λc,p\lambda_{c,p} is the factor of pattern pp in combination cc, u\mathbf{u} the displacements and s\mathbf{s} any force or stress result. Superposition holds only for a linear analysis. In a P-Delta or nonlinear analysis the combination is applied as one load and solved on its own, because the axial forces and the stiffness depend on the whole load.

A combination that contains response spectrum results, or another envelope, is reported as two envelopes, <name> max and <name> min, because a spectrum result is a magnitude without a sign (Section 12.5).

9.2 Typed combinations

Loads > Load combinations lists the combinations with their factors. Type a name and the factors in the form 1.2 G + 1.5 Q, using pattern names, and press Add. Each combination is of kind strength or service. The design reads the strength combinations; the drift and deflection checks of the Design Expert and the optimiser read the service combinations.

9.3 Generating combinations by code

Generate by code opens the combination wizard for the design code in the header:

  1. Choose the options of the code: for EN 1990, expression 6.10 or the pair 6.10a and 6.10b, and the category of the imposed load (for ψ); for ASCE 7-22, the ASD set and SDSS_{DS} for the vertical seismic effect; for AS/NZS 1170.0 and NBC 2020, storage occupancy; and the ψ factors where you want values other than the defaults.
  2. Check the type of every load pattern. The type decides the factors, so a wind pattern typed as other would be left out.
  3. Preview the list. Each row shows the combination, its factors and the clause it comes from.
  4. Create the combinations. Combinations you typed yourself are kept; replace generated removes earlier generated ones first.

Each wind pattern and each seismic pattern is combined on its own, so no combination holds two wind directions at once. Seismic patterns are applied with both signs where the code treats the earthquake action as reversible.

The generator also writes the envelopes All strength and All service (and All ASD for the US allowable stress set). An envelope gives, at every station and node, the largest and smallest value of each result over its combinations, each taken independently.

Where the code gives no factor for a pattern type in a combination, or the factor depends on data the generator does not hold, no combination is written for it and the preview lists the clause to check. You can then type a factor and the wizard writes one combination for that type, marked as your factor.

9.4 AS/NZS 1170.0

Table 9.1 Combinations generated for AS/NZS 1170.0:2002 (4.2.2 and 4.3)
ClauseCombinationKind
4.2.2(a)1.35G1.35Gstrength
4.2.2(b)1.2G+1.5Q1.2G + 1.5Qstrength
4.2.2(b)1.2G+1.5Q1.2G + 1.5Q (roof)strength
4.2.2(c)1.2G+1.5ψlQ1.2G + 1.5\psi_l Qstrength
4.2.2(d)1.2G+Wu+ψcQ1.2G + W_u + \psi_c Q, for each wind patternstrength
4.2.2(e)0.9G+Wu0.9G + W_u, for each wind patternstrength
4.2.2(f)G±Eu+ψEQG \pm E_u + \psi_E Q, for each seismic patternstrength
4.2.2(g)1.2G+Su+ψcQ1.2G + S_u + \psi_c Q, for each snow pattern; also for liquid FuF_u and earth HuH_ustrength
4.3G+ψsQG + \psi_s Q (short term)service
4.3G+ψlQG + \psi_l Q (long term)service

The factors are from AS/NZS 1170.0 Table 4.1: for floors ψc=0.4\psi_c = 0.4, ψl=0.4\psi_l = 0.4, ψE=0.3\psi_E = 0.3 and ψs=0.7\psi_s = 0.7; for storage ψc=ψl=ψE=0.6\psi_c = \psi_l = \psi_E = 0.6 and ψs=1.0\psi_s = 1.0; for roofs ψc=ψl=ψE=0\psi_c = \psi_l = \psi_E = 0. Notional horizontal forces (AS 4100 3.2.4) are added to the combinations of dead and live load only. For liquid and earth pressure the ultimate action enters with a factor of 1.0, so the pattern must hold the ultimate value from AS/NZS 1170.1 Section 4.

9.5 ASCE/SEI 7-22

Table 9.2 Combinations generated for ASCE/SEI 7-22 (2.3.1 and 2.3.6, strength design)
CombinationExpression
11.4D1.4D
21.2D+1.6L+(0.5Lr or 0.3S)1.2D + 1.6L + (0.5L_r \text{ or } 0.3S)
31.2D+(1.6Lr or 1.0S)+(L or 0.5W)1.2D + (1.6L_r \text{ or } 1.0S) + (L \text{ or } 0.5W)
41.2D+1.0W+L+(0.5Lr or 0.3S)1.2D + 1.0W + L + (0.5L_r \text{ or } 0.3S)
50.9D+1.0W0.9D + 1.0W
61.2D+Ev+Eh+L+0.15S1.2D + E_v + E_h + L + 0.15S, with Ev=0.2SDSDE_v = 0.2S_{DS}D
70.9D−Ev+Eh0.9D - E_v + E_h

Fluid load FF takes the factor of DD. Earth pressure HH takes 1.6 where it adds to the effect and 0.9 where it resists and is permanent. A temperature pattern takes your factor, not less than 1.0 (2.3.4). The load factor on LL in combinations 3 and 4 can be set to 0.5 for the exception of 2.3.1. Notional loads (AISC 360-22 C2.2b) are added to the gravity-only combinations.

The allowable stress combinations of 2.4.1 and 2.4.5 form a separate service-ASD set, which the strength design never uses. Service combinations (D+LD + L and others) follow the guidance of Appendix C, which gives no factors; with snow and wind the preview asks you to check Appendix C.

9.6 NBC 2020

Table 9.3 Combinations generated for NBC 2020 (Table 4.1.3.2.-A)
CasePrincipal and companion loads
11.4D1.4D
21.25D+1.5L1.25D + 1.5L, with 1.0S1.0S or 0.4W0.4W as companion
31.25D+1.5S1.25D + 1.5S, with 1.0L1.0L or 0.4W0.4W as companion
41.25D+1.4W1.25D + 1.4W, with 0.5L0.5L or 0.5S0.5S as companion
51.0D±1.0E+0.5L+0.25S1.0D \pm 1.0E + 0.5L + 0.25S

Cases 2 to 4 are also written with 0.9D0.9D where the dead load counteracts. Roof live load is treated as LL. Earth pressure HH (factor 1.5) and temperature TT (factor 1.25) are added as variants of the combinations with 1.25D1.25D, as Article 4.1.3.2.(4) allows. For storage occupancy the companion live load factor rises by 0.5. Importance factors belong in the load patterns. Liquids in tanks take 1.25 in case 2. Serviceability combinations follow Table 4.1.3.4: 1.0D+1.0L1.0D + 1.0L, 1.0D+1.0W1.0D + 1.0W and 1.0D+1.0S1.0D + 1.0S with their companion loads (0.3W, 0.35S, and 0.35L or 0.5L for storage). The creep case of Table 4.1.3.4, which needs the sustained and transitory parts of LL in two patterns, is not generated.

9.7 EN 1990

The fundamental combination uses expression 6.10,

∑jγG,jGk,j+γQ,1Qk,1+∑i>1γQ,i ψ0,i Qk,i(9.2)\sum_j \gamma_{G,j} G_{k,j} + \gamma_{Q,1} Q_{k,1} + \sum_{i>1} \gamma_{Q,i}\, \psi_{0,i}\, Q_{k,i} \tag{9.2}

or the less favourable of 6.10a and 6.10b,

∑jγG,jGk,j+γQ,1 ψ0,1Qk,1+∑i>1γQ,i ψ0,iQk,i(9.3)\sum_j \gamma_{G,j} G_{k,j} + \gamma_{Q,1}\,\psi_{0,1} Q_{k,1} + \sum_{i>1} \gamma_{Q,i}\,\psi_{0,i} Q_{k,i} \tag{9.3}
∑jξj γG,jGk,j+γQ,1Qk,1+∑i>1γQ,i ψ0,iQk,i(9.4)\sum_j \xi_j\,\gamma_{G,j} G_{k,j} + \gamma_{Q,1} Q_{k,1} + \sum_{i>1} \gamma_{Q,i}\,\psi_{0,i} Q_{k,i} \tag{9.4}

Each variable action leads in turn. With wind, a combination with the dead load favourable (γG,inf⁡G+γQW\gamma_{G,\inf} G + \gamma_Q W) is added for uplift and overturning. The seismic combination is 6.12b, G+AEd+∑ψ2,iQk,iG + A_{Ed} + \sum \psi_{2,i} Q_{k,i}, with both signs of AEdA_{Ed}.

The serviceability combinations are the characteristic (6.14b), frequent (6.15b) and quasi-permanent (6.16b) combinations:

G+Qk,1+∑i>1ψ0,iQk,i,G+ψ1,1Qk,1+∑i>1ψ2,iQk,i,G+∑iψ2,iQk,i(9.5)G + Q_{k,1} + \sum_{i>1}\psi_{0,i} Q_{k,i}, \qquad G + \psi_{1,1} Q_{k,1} + \sum_{i>1}\psi_{2,i} Q_{k,i}, \qquad G + \sum_i \psi_{2,i} Q_{k,i} \tag{9.5}

The partial factors, ξ\xi, the ψ factors and the choice of expression come from the National Annex selected in the app when one is loaded, and otherwise from the recommended values of Annex A1: γG,sup⁡=1.35\gamma_{G,\sup} = 1.35, γG,inf⁡=1.0\gamma_{G,\inf} = 1.0, γQ=1.5\gamma_Q = 1.5, ξ=0.85\xi = 0.85, and ψ from Table A1.1 (for category B imposed load ψ0=0.7\psi_0 = 0.7, ψ1=0.5\psi_1 = 0.5, ψ2=0.3\psi_2 = 0.3; snow below 1000 m 0.5, 0.2, 0; wind 0.6, 0.2, 0; temperature 0.6, 0.5, 0). Fluid, earth and notional patterns are not generated; the preview names EN 1990 A1.3.1 and EN 1993-1-1 5.3.2 for them.

9.8 Good practice

  • Give every pattern its true type before generating; the type, not the name, decides the factors.
  • Keep one pattern for each wind direction and each notional load direction.
  • Check the preview against the clause of each row, particularly for actions the generator leaves to you.
  • Run the linear analysis with all combinations, then use All strength in the Results tab to see the envelope of the design actions.